E*TRADE vs Tastytrade (2026) — Which Is Better?

Short answer: Both charge $0 for stocks. For options, E*TRADE charges $0.65 per contract ($0.50 with 30+ trades a quarter); tastytrade charges $1 to open, capped at $10 per leg, and $0 to close. tastytrade usually wins for frequent or large options trades; E*TRADE suits investors who also want a full-service broker.

Fact check, 12 Nov 2026

E*TRADEtastytrade
Stocks and ETFs$0 online$0
Options$0.65 per contract; $0.50 with 30+ trades a quarter$1 per contract to open (max $10 per leg), $0 to close
Account minimum$0—

Checked on each provider's official site on 12 Nov 2026. Prices and rules change, so confirm before you open an account. Where figures further down this page differ, these are the current ones. Sources: us.etrade.com · tastytrade.com

Compare E*TRADE and Tastytrade — features, pricing, pros and cons.

Numbers, fees, and platform capabilities cited here come from each vendor's public documentation. Confirm current pricing before you commit. Methodology →

Quick Verdict

Higher Rated

Tastytrade (4.4)

More Affordable

E*TRADE (Free)

E*TRADE

★★★★☆ 4.3/5

Morgan Stanley's online brokerage with Power E*TRADE for options trading, commission-free stocks, and comprehensive banking integration.

From: Free
Full review →

Tastytrade

★★★★★ 4.4/5

Options-first brokerage and trading platform built by the founders of thinkorswim, featuring $0 stock commissions, $1/contract options with no close fees, and tastylive — the largest live financial media network for options traders.

From: Free
Full review →

Fee & Feature Breakdown

Feature E*TRADE Tastytrade
Rating ★ 4.3 ★ 4.4
Starting Price Free Free
Free Tier Yes Yes
Markets stocks, options, futures stocks, options, futures, crypto
AI Analysis ✗ ✗
Backtesting ✗ ✗
Paper Trading ✓ ✓
Price Alerts ✓ ✓
Mobile App ✓ ✓
API Access ✗ ✓
Social Features ✗ ✗
Broker Integration ✓ ✓
Custom Indicators ✗ ✗
Automated Trading ✗ ✗
Trade Journaling ✗ ✗
Performance Analytics ✓ ✓
Risk Management ✓ ✓
News Feed ✓ ✓
Education Content ✓ ✓

Broker Head-to-Head

E*TRADE and Tastytrade both offer commission-free trading but target different audiences. E*TRADE, backed by Morgan Stanley, positions itself as a full-service platform with broad asset coverage and institutional research integration. Tastytrade has optimized exclusively for options traders, building probability-based tools and risk management into every feature. E*TRADE attracts traders seeking comprehensive market access; Tastytrade appeals to specialists willing to narrow their focus for superior execution.

The key differentiator is options pricing and educational approach. Tastytrade caps options commissions at $10 per leg—industry-leading for active traders—and includes Tastylive's streaming education built into the platform. E*TRADE offers volume-based discounts on options and Morgan Stanley research integration, plus Power E*TRADE's advanced backtesting and technical analysis tools. Tastytrade acknowledges charting limitations compared to competitors, while E*TRADE's charting remains serviceable but not specialized.

Choose Tastytrade if options comprise 80%+ of your trading activity—the $10 leg cap delivers substantial savings on frequent trades. E*TRADE suits diversified traders needing stocks, ETFs, and options access with institutional research, particularly those who may explore futures or other asset classes. Both platforms score 4.3-4.5 stars with identical core features (AI analysis, backtesting, paper trading, alerts, mobile apps), making the decision primarily about trading focus and pricing structure.

E*TRADE: Pros & Cons

Pros

  • + Power E*TRADE is excellent for options trading
  • + Morgan Stanley research integration
  • + Volume discounts on options commissions
  • + Strong mobile app experience

Cons

  • - No cryptocurrency trading
  • - Futures offerings are limited
  • - Banking features less robust than Schwab
  • - Platform can feel dated outside Power E*TRADE

Tastytrade: Pros & Cons

Pros

  • + Built by the founders of thinkorswim — Tom Sosnoff, Tony Battista, Scott Sheridan
  • + Cheapest options commissions: $1 to open, $0 to close, capped at $10/leg for large orders
  • + $0 stock and ETF commissions
  • + Platform purpose-built for options selling strategies — IV rank, probability of profit, and theta front and center
  • + tastylive media network: 8+ hours of live daily programming with data-driven options strategy analysis
  • + Follow Feed lets you see and optionally replicate trades from tastylive hosts
  • + Portfolio beta weighting shows entire portfolio exposure as a single number
  • + Well-designed mobile app with full trading capability
  • + Curve analysis with visual P&L diagrams integrated into the brokerage

Cons

  • - Basic charting compared to TradingView or thinkorswim — functional but limited
  • - No advanced scripting or custom indicator development
  • - No order flow tools — no footprint charts, volume profiles, or DOM
  • - No API for programmatic trading
  • - Limited stock research and fundamental analysis tools — options-focused platform
  • - 1% crypto trading fee is higher than dedicated crypto exchanges

Guides & Tutorials

Related Pages

You Might Also Compare

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you — that's what keeps this site free.